In this Microsoft Defender Antivirus review, I’ll cover everything you need to know about the cybersecurity tool. But is Windows Defender enough? In a world where online threats are evolving at an alarming pace, it’s natural to wonder whether the antivirus solution is enough to protect you.
Microsoft Defender Antivirus is part of the Windows Security suite and was formerly known as Windows Defender. It’s one of the most widely used antivirus solutions today, thanks to the fact it’s built into Windows. With the increasing sophistication of online threats, including malware and ransomware, however, you shouldn’t necessarily rely on it.
In this Microsoft Defender review, I’ll cover its strengths and weaknesses and the protection it provides against online threats. That said, it’s been beaten in malware protection testing by third-party providers, it doesn’t include additional security features, and it can only protect Windows desktops – so I recommend using an alternative like TotalAV.
- Show Full Guide
What is Microsoft Defender Antivirus?
The Windows Security suite also contains the Windows Firewall and receives regular updates. It can perform automatic scans of your machine to ensure your computer is kept safe at all times.
It’s important to note that it only offers basic protection, though, which is why I recommend opting for commercial solutions that can offer more advanced features to enhance your overall online security and provide multi-layered protection.
Confusingly, there’s also a product called Microsoft Defender, which is part of the paid Microsoft 365 subscription package.
Microsoft Defender Antivirus’ Performance
For an antivirus solution to receive high marks from me and my team, it needs to be able to perform well under testing.
This means pitting it against real-world threats like zero-day malware attacks, considering its impact on system performance, and looking at its usability and the frequency with which it incorrectly flags items as threats.
Here’s how Windows Security and Microsoft Defender Antivirus performed against the best antivirus software on the market under assessment by AV-Test.
Antivirus Solution | Protection | Performance | Usability |
---|---|---|---|
Microsoft Defender Antivirus | 5.5/6 | 6/6 | 6/6 |
TotalAV | 6/6 | 5.5/6 | 6/6 |
Bitdefender | 6/6 | 6/6 | 6/6 |
Norton Antivirus | 6/6 | 6/6 | 6/6 |
Surfshark Antivirus | 6/6 | 5.5/6 | 6/6 |
McAfee Antivirus | 6/6 | 6/6 | 6/6 |
Avast | 6/6 | 6/6 | 5.5/6 |
Microsoft Defender Antivirus caught 98.9% to 99.2% of zero-day threats and prevalent malware, had limited system impact, and only issued one false warning under independent testing. These are good results, and the Windows firewall and real-time protection tools work as expected.
Is Microsoft Defender good enough? It’s a good start, but Microsoft Defender was beaten in terms of overall score by Bitdefender, Norton Antivirus, and McAfee, and all of the third-party tools in the table above beat it for malware protection – indicating that better protection is readily available.
What’s more, to fully take advantage of these features, you’ll need to stick to using Microsoft products. That means the Windows Security suite won’t protect you if you use Chrome instead of Edge as your default browser.
It also doesn’t offer as many features as third-party solutions, either. For example, the best antivirus solutions often come bundled with a VPN, a password manager, dark web monitoring, and identity theft protection to deliver comprehensive security.
Because of this, the best free antivirus solutions from third-party providers will often provide better solutions than Microsoft Defender, while paid plans offer even more protection. See our guide to the best antivirus with VPN features for recommendations.
Microsoft Defender Antivirus’ Security Features
Microsoft has worked hard over the years to improve the capabilities of Microsoft Defender Antivirus. It’s easy to use, and minimal setup is needed. You’ll have access to the following features with Windows’ Defender security center:
Is Windows Security Enough?
So, is Windows Defender enough? The answer depends on your online habits and behavior. If you practice safe internet usage and avoid suspicious downloads and email attachments and ensuring your software remains up to date, then Microsoft Defender Antivirus may be enough.
Microsoft Defender Antivirus is completely free to use, so you have nothing to lose. If you have a Windows machine, it’s very likely to already be enabled and working.
Many antivirus solutions work alongside Windows Security, and having a second layer of security is never a bad idea, regardless of your internet habits.
Third-party solutions give you access to more advanced security features like phishing protection, identity theft protection, and a whole lot more. Some tests have also shown Windows Security has a chance of blocking legitimate software from working.
What You Won’t Get With Windows Security
Windows Security has a range of security features, but you’ll find it lacks some important features when compared to other antivirus solutions, including:
Virtual Private Network (VPN)
Many solutions bundle their antivirus packages with a VPN, which adds a layer of protection while you’re on the internet. Microsoft has yet to include this, however. The best VPNs are fantastic tools for security and privacy and often come with 256-bit AES encryption to protect your data and mask your IP address.
Password Manager
Password managers have become increasingly popular for managing online accounts. They can keep all your passwords in a secure location and auto-populate login pages, so you’ll never need to remember your passwords again.
The best password managers can generate strong, unique passwords for new accounts and keep them secure.
Dark Web Monitoring
Hackers use the dark web – which is only accessible with specialized software like Tor – to sell compromised data. If your details get leaked, it could have a devastating impact on your life.
That’s why it’s disappointing that Windows Security doesn’t offer data breach monitoring. This can detect if your data has been compromised or if there’s been an attempt to steal your identity before alerting you so you can take action. Early detection is a crucial step in preventing further damage being done.
Windows Security – Compatibility and Ease of Use
If you’re wondering how to set up Microsoft Defender Antivirus, there’s no need as it’s built-in, and there’s nothing you need to do – it runs in the background with no configuration or user interaction required.
Windows Security and the Microsoft Defender Antivirus are easy to use and are set to run and update automatically. If you install a third-party antivirus solution, Defender Antivirus will switch to inactive mode to prevent any potential conflicts or system impact.
The security suite is only available for Windows 10 and 11. On the other hand, Microsoft Defender, in the Microsoft 365 package, is available for Windows, Android, Mac, and iOS.
Best Practices for Using Windows Security
To get the most out of MS Defender, you should implement best practices for optimizing your computer security and take steps such as ensuring Windows is kept up to date with automatic updates and that scans are scheduled.
Other vital practices include a Windows Defender review to ensure all features are enabled. Turn on real-time protection, use the controlled folder access feature, enable SmartScreen, and ensure you use strong passwords. You might also consider using third-party solutions like a VPN for added security.
You should also use your own intuition. For example, if you receive an email with an attachment, it’s best not to download it unless you’re confident it’s safe. Also, try to avoid suspicious websites. If you find yourself on a site you don’t trust, run a scan immediately.
Alternatives to Microsoft Defender Antivirus aka Windows Defender
Let’s take a look at some of the best Microsoft Defender Antivirus alternatives. These are excellent options to pair up with Windows’ Defender as they have features the Microsoft antivirus software is missing.
Antivirus Software | Starting Price | Independent Test | Max Devices | Free Version | Key Features |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
TotalAV | $19/year | 17.5/18 | 8 | Free plan | Identity Protection, System Optimization, Password Manager |
Bitdefender | $23.99/year | 18/18 | 10 | Free plan | Real-Time Protection, Privacy Firewall, Safepay Browser |
Norton Antivirus | $29.99/year | 18/18 | Unlimited | 30-day trial | 100% Virus Protection Promise, Encrypted Storage, Password Manager |
Surfshark Antivirus | $34.86/year | 17.5/18 | 5 | 7-day VPN trial on Google Play Store | Real-Time Protection, Fast VPN, Private Search |
McAfee Antivirus | $39.99/year | 18/18 | Unlimited | 30-day trial | Protection Score, Social Privacy Manager, VPN |
Avast | $35.88/year | 17.5/18 | 30 | Free plan | Webcam Shield, Strong Mobile Apps, Free Plan |
These solutions have lots to offer, which makes them good choices for those looking for antivirus protection. Third-party antivirus solutions offer the ability to cover multiple devices on a single subscription, giving you more control over your device security while keeping all the required information in a central dashboard for easy monitoring.
The Microsoft Antivirus Defender only protects the device it’s on and can’t extend its capabilities to other devices, such as mobile phones or tablets. Because of this, it’s generally the weaker option in comparisons like Windows Defender vs McAfee.
For our recommendations for different operating systems, see our guides to the best antivirus for Android, the best antivirus for MacOS, and the best antivirus for Chromebook.
How We Review And Test Antivirus Software
15 Antiviruses Tested
20 Datapoints Measured
300+ Hours Testing
500+ User Reviews Read
We base our recommendations on first-hand experience and in-depth testing. All the Antivirus products we suggest, have been tested based on the following criteria:
- Core Security Features: We make sure that the antivirus software is fully equipped with features like real-time protection, scanning, a firewall, web protection, and more.
- Malware Detection Rates: We test malware detection rates ourselves by running both in-depth and quick scans on our devices. Additionally, we check independent lab tests.
- Compatibility: We check which devices and operating systems the antivirus software is compatible with. Often, different-looking dashboards and slightly different packages of features may be available.
- Performance Impact: A reliable and functional antivirus should not slow down your device significantly. So, we examine our device performance with and without the antivirus running.
- Customer Experience: Alongside our own experience, we are curious to know what real users have to say regarding the services. So, we’ve scoured the web for feedback on each of our tested antiviruses.
- Value for Money: We always consider value for money and how much each product is offering for the set price point.
FAQs
Is Microsoft Defender Antivirus any good?
Is Windows Security enough on its own?
Is Microsoft Defender Antivirus free?
Does Windows 11 need antivirus protection?
Is Windows Security good enough for small business needs?
Can Microsoft Defender Antivirus remove malware?
References
- Windows Antivirus home testing (AV-Test)
- Microsoft Defender Windows test results (AV-Test)
- Cybersecurity Awareness Month 2021 – Phishing Tip Sheet (CISA)
- Secure Yourself & Your Family (CISA)
- TotalAV Windows test results (AV-Test)
- Bitdefender Internet Security Windows test results (AV-Test)
- Norton Internet Security Windows test results (AV-Test)
- Surfshark Antivirus Windows test results (AV-Test)
- McAfee Internet Security Windows test results (AV-Test)
- Avast Free Antivirus Windows test results (AV-Test)