1Password vs Bitwarden – Which One is Better?

The 1Password vs Bitwarden comparison often comes up for people choosing a password manager, and both tools offer a comprehensive set of features to keep your passwords safe, secure, and easily accessible.

While they share some similarities, each tool has its own approach to password management. In this guide, we’ll take a closer look at the differences between these two password managers to help you determine which one best suits your needs.

We’ll compare Bitwarden vs 1Password based on factors such as security, ease of use, pricing, and additional features to provide a clear picture of each tool’s strengths and weaknesses and help you choose the best password manager for your digital life.

Table of Contents Table of Contents

1. Bitwarden vs 1Password Compared
2. 1Password vs Bitwarden Pricing Compared
3. 1Password or Bitwarden – Which One is Safer?
4. 1Password vs Bitwarden – Ease of Use
5. Bitwarden vs. 1Password – Key Features
6. 1Password vs. Bitwarden – Compatibility
7. 1Password vs Bitwarden Customer Reviews
8. Conclusion – 1Password vs Bitwarden – Which One Wins?
9. How We Test Password Managers
10. How to Choose the Best Password Manager
11. Our Other Password Manager Guides
12. FAQs
13. References

Show Full Guide

Table of Contents

1. Bitwarden vs 1Password Compared
2. 1Password vs Bitwarden Pricing Compared
3. 1Password or Bitwarden – Which One is Safer?
Show Full Guide
4. 1Password vs Bitwarden – Ease of Use
5. Bitwarden vs. 1Password – Key Features
6. 1Password vs. Bitwarden – Compatibility
7. 1Password vs Bitwarden Customer Reviews
8. Conclusion – 1Password vs Bitwarden – Which One Wins?
9. How We Test Password Managers
10. How to Choose the Best Password Manager
11. Our Other Password Manager Guides
12. FAQs
13. References

Bitwarden vs 1Password Compared

Before we go deeper into the details, let’s take a look at how Bitwarden and 1Password compare across key areas.

1Password vs Bitwarden Pricing Compared

Choosing between Bitwarden or 1Password can be daunting, especially when you’re trying to balance security with affordability. In this section, we’ll dive into the pricing plans of these two popular password managers to help you determine which one is the best fit for your needs.

When comparing the plans for individuals, families, and businesses, Bitwarden consistently offers more affordable options.

Unlike 1Password, Bitwarden also offers a free plan, and it includes organization groupings for up to two users with two collections. This makes it an attractive choice for those who want to try out a password manager without any upfront costs.

For individuals, Bitwarden’s $0.83/month plan is significantly cheaper than 1Password’s $2.99/month starter plan while still providing essential features like two-factor authentication, emergency access, file attachments, and vault health reports.

Bitwarden’s $3.33/month family plan supports up to six users and includes premium features such as unlimited shared vaults, unlimited sharing, and additional storage. 1Password’s family plan costs $4.99/month plan for up to five members, making Bitwarden a more cost-effective choice for families.

In the business category, 1Password’s team plan starts at $19.95/month for up to ten users, while Bitwarden offers a lower absolute price of $4/month per user.

For enterprise solutions, Bitwarden charges $6/month per user, undercutting 1Password’s $7.99/month per user Business plan and its 75+ user Enterprise plan, which is available with a custom quote.

Unless you require specific features exclusive to 1Password, Bitwarden is the more budget-friendly option for individuals, families, and businesses.

For in-depth analysis, you can also read our full 1Password review and our comprehensive Bitwarden review. For additional product comparisons, see our Dashlane vs 1Password guide.

1Password or Bitwarden – Which One is Safer?

1Password and Bitwarden are highly regarded password managers, but after a thorough comparison of their security features, 1Password emerges as the safer choice. In this section, we’ll detail the encryption, data storage, and privacy policies of both providers to explore why 1Password comes out on top.

Encryption

Both 1Password and Bitwarden employ strong encryption to protect user data. 1Password uses AES-GCM-256 encryption, which is considered the gold standard in symmetric key cryptography. Bitwarden uses AES-CBC-256 encryption, which is also secure but slightly less efficient than GCM.

1Password also employs a unique user Secret Key. This 128-bit key is used with the Master Password – a single account password – to encrypt and decrypt data. The additional layer of security ensures that even if encrypted data is obtained, it can’t be decrypted without the Secret Key.

Data Storage

1Password stores user data on its servers in an encrypted format, with the encryption keys being derived from the user’s Master Password and Secret Key.

Bitwarden also stores encrypted user data on its servers but takes a different approach. Its encryption keys are derived from the user Master Password, which is hashed on the client side before being sent to the server. This is secure but lacks the additional protection provided by 1Password’s Secret Key.

Privacy Policy

Bitwarden’s privacy policy is more transparent and straightforward than that of 1Password.

Bitwarden clearly states that it does not collect or store any user data except for basic account information necessary for providing the service. In contrast, 1Password’s privacy policy is more complex and allows for the collection of certain usage data.

Bitwarden’s open source password manager model also contributes to its superior privacy, as the source code can be audited by security experts and the community to ensure no hidden vulnerabilities or data collection mechanisms exist. 1Password, being a closed-source solution, lacks this level of transparency.

That said, both providers have bug bounty programs, with 1Password offering up to $1m and Bitwarden running its own Vulnerability Disclosure Program.

1Password vs Bitwarden – Ease of Use

When it comes to usability, both 1Password and Bitwarden offer user-friendly interfaces that cater to both novice and experienced users. However, 1Password holds a slight advantage in this category.

Its sleek and intuitive design makes it easy for first-time users to navigate and manage their passwords. The app’s layout is clean and well-organized, with clear labels and icons that guide users through the process of creating, storing, and accessing their passwords.

1Password also offers a helpful onboarding process that walks users through the setup and key features, ensuring a smooth transition into using the software.

On the other hand, the Bitwarden UI, while functional and efficient, may feel a bit more technical and less visually appealing. Its straightforward approach is well-suited for experienced users who prioritize functionality over aesthetics, though.

The app’s minimalist design allows users to quickly access and manage their passwords without any unnecessary extras.

Bitwarden vs. 1Password – Key Features

1Password edges out Bitwarden when it comes to key features. While both are excellent password managers with robust core functionality, and both allow you to store unlimited passwords and access them with unlimited devices, 1Password offers a few additional security features and more polished sharing and business capabilities that make it the better choice overall.

In this section, we’ll compare Bitwarden to 1Password in terms of its core and advanced features.

Password Generator

Both Bitwarden and 1Password include built-in password generators to help you create strong, unique passwords.

With Bitwarden, you can specify the length from 5 to 128 characters, whether to use uppercase letters, lowercase letters, numbers, and symbols, and whether to avoid ambiguous characters. You can also generate passphrases.

The 1Password password generator provides a few more options, letting you choose a memorable password or PIN code, use a custom word list, and create separate passwords for different websites based on a single master password using the Smart Password feature.

While Bitwarden’s generator covers the essentials, 1Password’s offers a bit more flexibility and convenience.

Password Sharing

1Password offers a more comprehensive and flexible password-sharing solution than Bitwarden, which tailors its sharing features based on the user’s plan, limiting its usefulness for teams.

Bitwarden’s Free and Premium plans allow sharing passwords and other sensitive data with only one other user, making it less suitable for groups and organizations.

However, the Families plan expands this capability, enabling sharing with up to six users, making it suitable for small groups or households. Bitwarden also offers a secure file-sharing tool called Bitwarden Send, allowing users to encrypt and share files securely, regardless of their plan.

With 1Password, users can create secure sharing links for passwords and other vault items, granting access to specific recipients. These links can have expiration dates set and can be deleted, adding extra layers of control.

Family plan users can also access shared vaults and can easily share passwords with one another, and these capabilities also transfer over to teams and businesses using higher-tier 1Password plans for seamless collaboration.

Other Security Features

1Password offers a comprehensive suite of advanced security features. Its Watchtower feature monitors for password breaches and supplying security reports, while Travel Mode ensures sensitive data is inaccessible while you’re traveling.

The Secret Key and Secure Remote Password (SRP) protocols add robust encryption, making it virtually impossible for anyone to access your data without the proper credentials.

1Password’s Multi-Factor Authentication (MFA) implementation is also more user-friendly and more deeply integrated, supporting various methods like one-time passwords, biometrics, and physical security keys. This provides an extra layer of protection for user accounts. You can also use both platforms as authentication apps for other services.

Both providers offer tools to automatically clear your clipboard to remove sensitive information. Both also include email masking tools, allowing you to sign up for services with aliases and protect your real credentials.

While Bitwarden prioritizes security with end-to-end encryption and encrypted cloud storage, its feature set lags behind 1Password’s offerings. As an open-source solution, though, Bitwarden’s codebase is publicly available for scrutiny, enhancing transparency and adding to its security credentials.

When comparing 1Password vs Bitwarden security, however, 1Password’s approach is more thorough, and its comprehensive feature set caters to a broader range of user needs and use cases.

1Password vs. Bitwarden – Compatibility

Both 1Password and Bitwarden offer extensive compatibility across platforms and devices. However, Bitwarden takes the lead in terms of overall compatibility and the number of supported devices.

1Password is compatible with major operating systems such as Windows, macOS, Linux, ChromeOS, iOS, and Android. It provides browser extensions for popular web browsers such as Chrome, Firefox, Safari, Edge, and Brave. Additionally, 1Password offers a command-line tool for advanced users and integration with apps like Slack.

On the other hand, Bitwarden has an even wider range of compatibility. It supports all the platforms and browsers mentioned above for 1Password but also extends its reach to less common browsers with browser extension compatibility for Opera, Tor Browser, and Vivaldi.

Bitwarden also provides a self-hosted option, allowing users to run their own password management server on platforms like Docker, Kubernetes, and Raspberry Pi, meaning your data would live on your own infrastructure rather than Bitwarden’s cloud-hosted servers.

Because of this, when comparing 1Password to Bitwarden for compatibility, Bitwarden comes out on top.

1Password vs Bitwarden Customer Reviews

When it comes to choosing a password manager, one of the best ways to gauge real-world performance and user experience is with customer reviews. On Trustpilot, 1Password stands out with an “Excellent” overall rating of 4.7 out of 5 stars from over 11,500 user reviews.

In comparison, Bitwarden has a “Great” rating of 4.0 out of 5 stars, based on around 100 customer reviews on the same platform.

The majority of reviews for 1Password are highly positive, with users praising the excellent customer support, user-friendly interface, and robust security features. Many customers shared instances of issues being quickly resolved and customer support staff being knowledgeable and helpful, making their experiences with 1Password very positive.

User review from Trustpilot

1Password is not without its drawbacks, though. Some negative reviews highlight issues with pricing and difficulties during the setup or migration process.

Bitwarden has also received its fair share of positive reviews. Users highlight Bitwarden’s affordability, with its free tier offering a comprehensive set of features and more than providers like Norton Password Manager.

Trustpilot user review

The open-source nature of Bitwarden and its robust security features are also much appreciated by its customers.

However, some reviews mention the complexity involved in setup and use, with users finding it challenging to navigate features like vaults, collections, and organizations. There’s also some negative feedback about the lack of certain advanced features some users expected.

Read more customer reviews for Bitwarden on Trustpilot and 1Password user feedback.

Conclusion – 1Password vs Bitwarden – Which One Wins?

When comparing Bitwarden vs 1Password, it’s clear that both password management solutions have strengths, but 1Password emerges as the better choice for most users.

While Bitwarden offers affordability and broad compatibility, 1Password excels in critical areas such as security, ease of use, features, and customer satisfaction.

Those who prioritize cost savings and the ability to use the software across multiple platforms may find Bitwarden to be the better choice, but for the majority of users, 1Password offers a more comprehensive and user-friendly solution.

How We Test Password Managers

To ensure our readers get the most reliable and comprehensive information when choosing a password manager, we subject each tool to a rigorous testing process. Our methodology focuses on several key aspects:

• Features – We assess the range of features offered by each password manager to determine which tools provide the most robust and practical solutions for users.
• Ease of use – We evaluate the user interface, navigation, and overall user experience of each password manager to ensure that it’s intuitive and accessible for users of all skill levels.
• Security – We examine each password manager’s encryption methods, storage practices, and overall security to ensure user data remains protected at all times.
• Third-Party Reviews – We take into account independent security audits and customer feedback to get a well-rounded perspective on each password manager’s reputation and reliability within the industry.
• Pricing – We compare the pricing structure of various password managers, considering factors such as subscription plans, free versions, and value for money.

How to Choose the Best Password Manager

When choosing the best password manager, it’s essential to consider a variety of factors to ensure you select a secure, user-friendly solution with all the features you need. By evaluating the following criteria, you can find the perfect password manager for your requirements:

• Security and encryption – The password manager should have robust security measures and no history of leaks or breaches.
• Password importing and exporting – It should allow seamless importing and exporting of your password vault between services for easy transitions.
• Ease of use – The password keeper should ensure a smooth user experience with an intuitive interface and no requirements for extensive training.
• Compatibility – The provider should offer mobile apps and integrations that work with your devices and platforms.
• Key features – The service should have features that align with your needs and budget. Consider essentials such as two-factor authentication, secure password sharing, and password generation. Also, look for advanced features like encrypted file storage and dark web monitoring, which may be restricted to higher-tier plans.
• Customer support – The password manager should have adequate support hours, communication methods, and positive user reviews to indicate the quality and responsiveness of its customer service team.
• Price – The password manager should provide good value for money, taking into account any additional features included in the plan you’re considering. Compare the pricing of different password managers, looking for those that offer a balance of essential features and affordability while also considering any extra benefits or discounts available with long-term subscriptions and family plans.

Our Other Password Manager Guides

Going beyond Bitwarden-1Password, our team of cybersecurity experts have created a wide range of resources covering other password managers for different use cases. These include:

• Best Password Manager for Windows
• Best Password Managers for Android
• Best Chrome Password Managers
• Best Firefox Password Managers

FAQs