Part of:

Enhancing Language Models: How Your Feedback Transforms LMs like ChatGPT


User feedback plays a crucial role in enhancing language models like ChatGPT. Through reinforcement learning, these models learn from their errors and continually improve. This iterative feedback process is instrumental in addressing challenges such as bias, fabrication, contradictions, and inaccuracies, resulting in more accurate and reliable language generation.

Language models like ChatGPT have transformed our interactions with technology. They assist us in tasks like answering questions, giving recommendations, and engaging in conversations.


What many users may not realize is that while we benefit from these language models, they also learn and improve from the feedback we provide.

This article explores the relationship between users and language models, emphasizing how user feedback shapes and enhances the performance of tools like ChatGPT.


What Is a Language Model?

As the name suggests, a language model is a specialized artificial intelligence (AI) algorithm designed to replicate a human’s ability to comprehend and create natural language. To achieve this goal, the algorithm is trained on a large amount of written text gathered from different sources like books, articles, and websites. This extensive training provides the algorithm with the necessary experience to learn and comprehend natural language effectively.

The training is usually performed by asking the algorithm to predict the next word in a sentence based on a given set of initial words. By repeatedly performing this task, the algorithm learns the patterns and relationships between words. This process enables the algorithm to improve its understanding of language and ability to generate text.

With this training, the algorithm can answer questions, have conversations, and be useful in applications like chatbots and virtual assistants.


Challenges of Language Models

Although language models have many advantages, they do have some drawbacks. As the models are trained on vast amounts of text data that may have both correct and incorrect information, sometimes these models can give incorrect or contradictory answers.

They can also be influenced by biases present in the data and may return biased responses. In some cases, they can even generate made-up information that isn’t based on facts. Contradictory statements may arise when the model contradicts itself within a given context. A detailed description of these challenges is provided in our Language Model Users Beware: 4 Pitfalls to Keep in Mind article.

To address these limitations, one common approach is to rely on human feedback to improve the performance of models. By receiving feedback, the models can learn from their errors and gradually enhance their abilities. This continuous learning process, driven by feedback, refines the models’ understanding of language and enables them to generate more precise and dependable responses.

Understanding the concept of reinforcement learning and its workings is crucial to appreciate how language models benefit from user feedback.

What Is Reinforcement Learning?

Reinforcement Learning (RL) is a powerful AI technique where a computer system learns by trial and error. Inspired by how humans and animals learn from their environment, RL enables the system to experiment, receive feedback in the form of rewards or punishments, and gradually improve its decision-making abilities.

The core idea in RL is the interaction between an agent (e.g., a robot or software) and its environment. The agent takes actions, receives rewards or penalties based on the outcomes, and learns which actions are favorable or should be avoided.

Over time, it discovers strategies that maximize overall cumulative rewards.

An illustrative example
Imagine teaching your pet robot, RoboDog, how to fetch a ball. Equipped with a camera, sensors, and wheels, RoboDog starts off with no knowledge of what to do. Through trial and error, it randomly moves around and occasionally hits the ball. You reward RoboDog with treats whenever it accidentally succeeds. Over time, RoboDog learns that hitting the ball yields positive outcomes. Through exploration, it discovers the actions that result in the most treats, specifically moving towards and picking up the ball. By focusing on these rewarding actions, RoboDog refines its strategy and becomes skilled at efficiently fetching the ball, even navigating obstacles. Its learning process is based on trial and error, guided by rewards.

Types of Reinforcement Learning Methods


Two main approaches to performing reinforcement learning are value-based and policy-based methods.

Value-based method This deals with estimating the value of actions or states based on rewards, like figuring out the value of moves in a game. In the RoboDog example, it learns which actions, like moving towards the ball or picking it up, lead to higher rewards (treats) and are, therefore, more valuable.

By estimating these values, the method learns to prioritize actions that yield better outcomes.

Policy-based method It focuses on learning the best actions directly, without estimating values, like finding the optimal strategy for RoboDog without knowing the value of each move explicitly.

Reinforcement learning algorithms can also be categorized into model-free and model-based algorithms.

Model-free algorithm It directly learns from experiences by trial and error, just like RoboDog randomly tries different actions and gets rewarded with treats when it accidentally hits the ball. This way, it learns which actions result in the most treats and gets better at fetching over time.

The most commonly used model-free algorithm is Q-learning. The algorithm estimates the best actions to take by assigning values to different actions. It starts with random values and updates them based on the rewards it receives.

Model-based algorithm It builds an internal model to predict outcomes in different situations. It’s like RoboDog has created a plan using a built-in understanding of the environment.

The algorithm predicts the outcomes of different actions and uses that information to make decisions.

How Does a Language Model Use User Feedback to Improve?

Language models employ reinforcement learning to leverage user feedback and improve their performance in tackling challenges such as biased, fabricated, contradictory, and incorrect responses. As described above, reinforcement learning works like a feedback loop.

The language model takes input from users and generates responses. Users then give feedback on how good those responses are, letting the model know if they’re satisfactory or not. This feedback is like a reward signal for the model’s learning.

The model takes this feedback and adjusts its internal settings to improve its response generation process. It uses algorithms like policy gradients or Q-learning to update its parameters in a way that maximizes the rewards it receives from user feedback.

If the model produces a biased, made-up, contradictory, or incorrect response, negative feedback helps it recognize and fix those mistakes. The model updates its underlying mechanisms, like the connections and weights in its neural network, to reduce the chances of making those errors in the future.

Through this ongoing process of receiving feedback, updating parameters, and generating better responses, the model gradually gets better at understanding language. This leads to more accurate and reliable outputs.

The Bottom Line

Language models like ChatGPT benefit from user feedback through reinforcement learning. By receiving feedback on their responses, these models can learn from their mistakes and improve over time.

This iterative process of feedback and adjustment helps address challenges such as biased, fabricated, contradictory, and incorrect responses, leading to more accurate and reliable language generation.


Related Terms

Dr. Tehseen Zia

Dr. Tehseen Zia has Doctorate and more than 10 years of post-Doctorate research experience in Artificial Intelligence (AI). He is Tenured Associate Professor and leads AI research at Comsats University Islamabad, and co-principle investigator in National Center of Artificial Intelligence Pakistan. In the past, he has worked as research consultant on European Union funded AI project Dream4cars.